Legislation Details

File #: 26-2262    Version: 1
Type: Discussion Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/29/2026 In control: City Council
On agenda: 11/17/2026 Final action: 11/17/2026
Effective date:    
Title: Appeal of the Denial of an Encroachment Permit for a Second Driveway at 38765 Clearbrook Drive
Attachments: 1. ATT 1 - Murrieta Informational Bulletin 229, 2. ATT 2 - Application for Encroachment Permit, 3. ATT 3 - Notice of Encroachment Permit Denial, 4. ATT 4 - Site Plan for Driveway Analysis, 5. ATT 5 - Notice of Appeal, 6. ATT 6 - Resolution No. 26-4976, 7. Received After Agenda Printed - PowerPoint
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

TO:                                                                HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL

 

FROM:                                           Bob Moehling, Public Works Director

 

PREPARED BY:                      Jeff Hitch, City Engineer

 

SUBJECT:

title

Appeal of the Denial of an Encroachment Permit for a Second Driveway at 38765 Clearbrook Drive

end

ABSTRACT

The City Council will consider an appeal of the denial of an encroachment permit to construct a second driveway apron within the public right-of-way at 38765 Clearbrook Drive. Staff recommends denying the appeal and upholding the permit denial due to inadequate sight distance and the potential creation of a dangerous condition within the public right-of-way.


RECOMMENDATION

recommendation

Adopt Resolution No. 26-4976 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California Denying the Appeal of the Denial of an Encroachment Permit for A Second Driveway Apron at 38765 Clearbrook Drive and Upholding the Decision of the Department of Public Works & Engineering.

 

body

PRIOR ACTION/VOTE

On October 6, 2026, the City Council considered the Tarlecki appeal of an encroachment permit with the item continued to November 17, 2026.


STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT

This item aligns with the City Council goal to: foster and promote an engaged, connected and caring community.

 

DISCUSSION

Mr. Dennis Tarlecki owns a residential property at 38765 Clearbrook Drive. On October 6, 2026, the City Council considered the appeal of an encroachment permit denial filed by Mr. Dennis Tarlecki to add a second driveway apron within the public right-of-way. The City Council elected to continue the item to allow staff time to further evaluate materials provided by and to investigate statements made by Mr. Tarlecki during the appeal.

 

Background

 

Mr. Tarlecki owns a residential property at 38765 Clearbrook Drive. On December 18, 2025, Mr. Tarlecki filed an application for an encroachment permit (Attachment 2) to add a second driveway apron within the public right-of-way on his property to allow him to drive over the right-of-way to park vehicles in his yard behind a fence. The application was denied. Mr. Tarlecki subsequently approached staff requesting a reconsideration of his application, and staff realized that Mr. Tarlecki had not been advised of his appeal right in writing. Accordingly, Mr. Tarlecki was asked to resubmit his application. On July 1, 2026, Mr. Tarlecki filed a subsequent application for an encroachment permit to add a second driveway apron in the public right-of-way. On July 9, 2026, the City issued a Notice of Encroachment Permit Denial (Attachment 3) explaining that the permit was denied because it does not meet the City’s design standard due to inadequate sight distance. The Site Plan used in the City’s analysis of the application is Attachment 4.

 

Applicable Law

 

The City has an obligation to maintain sidewalks and roadways in a safe condition. Under California's Government Claims Act, a public entity may be held liable for injuries caused by a "dangerous condition" of its property when a plaintiff satisfies the four elements of Government Code Section 835: (1) the property was in a dangerous condition at the time of injury; (2) the dangerous condition proximately caused the injury; (3) the condition created a reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of injury incurred; and (4) either a public employee's negligent or wrongful act created the condition, or the public entity had actual or constructive notice of the condition a sufficient time before the injury to have taken protective measures. Hence, the City should not issue an encroachment permit for a second driveway in a location where doing so could create a dangerous condition. Mr. Tarlecki’s application is seeking a second driveway in a location where the road curves, likely obscuring visibility for drivers, cyclists, and pedestrians.

 

The location of the proposed second driveway on a curved road unfortunately creates a dangerous condition of public property by: foreseeably increasing collision risk as sight distances are inherently limited on curves; introducing additional conflict points between turning vehicles, through traffic, cyclists, and pedestrians; and disrupting the continuity and accessibility of the pedestrian path of travel, including ADA compliance on sidewalks. All of these elevate foreseeable hazards to road users and expose the public right-of-way to avoidable risks.

 

The Appeal

 

On July 16, 2026, Mr. Tarlecki filed a timely appeal of the denial of the permit pursuant to Murrieta Municipal Code (MMC) Section 15.54.280. The appeal and all documents in support of the appeal submitted by Mr. Tarlecki are Attachment 5.

 

Mr. Tarlecki provided a handout during the October 6, 2026, City Council meeting to support his appeal. Below is a brief summary of several of the issues presented and staff’s response with recommended action.

 

Sight Distance

Mr. Tarlecki questioned the City’s determination of a dangerous condition due to inadequate sight distance. During the appeal Mr. Tarlecki presented a handout analyzing sight distance and reached the conclusion that the driveway met applicable standards. However, Mr. Tarlecki used a different standard for sight distances than the City would use in this circumstance. The City utilizes Corner Sight Distance to address a vehicle entering a roadway from a driveway or intersection. This is set forth in City of Murrieta Standard Drawing No. 214 (COM 214), which is shown below for reference:

 

Corner Sight Distance is usually used for private and public road intersections or for rural driveways. Corner Sight Distance is not always applied to urban driveway applications to allow the main driveway to a residential home to exist even though there may be an obstruction. However, a second driveway in a residential community is optional, not required, to maintain access to the property, therefore, it is not given the same leeway, and the City should require compliance with COM 214 when reviewing a second driveway. Having limited sight distance from a secondary driveway permitted by the City could put the City at risk of creating an unnecessary dangerous condition, which could result in an injury.

 

Sight Distance Recommendation: Staff recommends compliance with the City’s standard, COM 214, for any second driveway to ensure Corner Sight Distance requirements can be met using a design speed of 30 MPH.

 

Speed Limits:

Speed limits are established based on the criteria outlined in the California Vehicle Code (CVC). Clearbrook Drive is not currently posted with a regulatory speed limit, although a 15 mph warning speed is posted due to the speed hump installed on the street. The portion of Clearbrook Drive with homes fronting is in a residential district. The CVC defines a residential district as a street with 13 or more separate dwelling units (homes) on one side of the roadway, within a quarter mile or 16 or more dwelling units on both sides within a quarter mile. Residential districts have a set prima facie speed limit of 25 miles per hour (MPH).

 

The applicable portion of Clearbrook Drive with homes is a residential district resulting in a 25 MPH prima facie speed limit. If the City were to set a speed limit sign lower than 25 MPH, it likely would not be enforceable. Lowering a speed limit where that lower speed is not enforceable arguably creates a dangerous condition. The 650 linear foot portion of Clearbrook Drive between Via Princesa and the residential homes could be considered outside of the residential district as it has no homes fronting it. This could make this portion subject to setting the speed limit based on the 85th percentile speed of an engineered speed survey. Prior speed surveys on Clearbrook Drive disclosed the following:

 

•                     2005 to 2012: Prior to the installation of speed humps, various speed surveys were conducted, on Clearbrook Drive, measured midway between Via Princesa and Branwin Street. The 85th percentile speeds from those surveys ranged from 29 to 32 MPH

•                     2015: Post speed hump installation, the 85th percentile speed was 27 MPH.

 

Speed Limit Recommendation: Staff recommends leaving Clearbrook Drive unposted but continuing to utilize a design speed of 30 MPH for corner sight distance calculations.

 

PUBLIC NOTICING

The agenda item has been noticed according to the Brown Act (72 hours in advance of the meeting at which the City Council considers the item).

 

FISCAL IMPACT

There is no fiscal impact associated with this item.


ATTACHMENTS

ATT 1 - Murrieta Informational Bulletin 229

ATT 2 - Application for Encroachment Permit

ATT 3 - Notice of Encroachment Permit Denial

ATT 4 - Site Plan for Driveway Analysis

ATT 5 - Notice of Appeal

ATT 6 - Resolution No. 26-4976